Plan a Counterclaim and Rebuttal Paragraph
Written by Adi Ackerman, Head Teacher
"Plan a Counterclaim and Rebuttal Paragraph" is written for 5th Grade (Ages 10-11), and it covers Common Core W.5.1. If your little one is a year younger but already steady on opinion writing, the page still works. You may just need to read the instructions out loud. And if they are older and writing counter arguments never quite stuck, this is a short review rather than busywork.
5th grade writing worksheet: read a made-up model about video games as a sport, then plan a counterclaim and rebuttal on learning a second language. Part of our writing counter arguments collection. Aligned to Common Core standards.
How do I use this worksheet?
Take turns arguing each side of a question out loud before writing. Then have your child write the other side's best point in the counterclaim box and answer it.
What students will practice
- Students will name the other side's claim.
- Students will write a rebuttal with evidence.
- Students will close with their own claim again.
Curriculum Links
Common Core State Standards
Writing · 5th Grade
Standard: Write opinion pieces on topics or texts, supporting a point of view with reasons and information.
View all W.5.1 worksheets →Find this in the curriculum
Browse the grade, subject, and topic this belongs to.
FAQ
How do I use this writing counter arguments worksheet?
⌄
Take turns arguing each side of a question out loud before writing. Then have your child write the other side's best point in the counterclaim box and answer it.
What does this worksheet teach?
⌄
Read a made-up model about video games as a sport, then plan a counterclaim and rebuttal on learning a second language. A rebuttal answers a counterclaim, the other side's claim. The directions on the page read: Read the topic and the model. Then, write your claim. Then, write the counterclaim and their evidence. Then, write your rebuttal with evidence. Then, write a closing. Then, use your plan to write your draft on lined paper.
Can I use this writing counter arguments worksheet for homeschool or classroom?
⌄
Yes, both. We made it for 5th Grade opinion writing, and the page works the same whether it lands on a kitchen table or a center rotation. At home, most families go through it together and talk the answers out loud, and that talking is where most of the learning happens with writing counter arguments. In class it runs well as independent work while you pull a small group. Print one copy or thirty, whichever the day needs.
What is a counterclaim?
⌄
A counterclaim is the other side's claim, like some say gaming takes skill, like a sport. Naming it shows the writer has thought about both sides.
What is a rebuttal?
⌄
A rebuttal answers the counterclaim and explains why the writer still disagrees, with evidence. The planner has boxes for the counterclaim, the other side's evidence, the rebuttal and your evidence.
Is answering the other side a 5th grade standard?
⌄
Counterclaims are formally part of the 7th grade standards. In 5th grade they support W.5.1, writing an opinion with reasons and information, and give students an early start.
Is there an answer key?
⌄
The opinion and response page has one. The rebuttal planner is open, so check that the rebuttal answers the counterclaim and has evidence.
Ratings & Reviews
No reviews yet. Be the first to share what you think.
Reviews are for ClassWeekly members.
Make a Request
Spotted something to fix, or want a worksheet we don't have yet? Tell us and we'll make it.
Worksheet Details
| Grade | 5th Grade |
| Subject | Grammar & Writing |
| Topic | Opinion Writing |
| Standard | W.5.1 |
| Pages | 1 page |
| Difficulty | Medium |
What is ClassWeekly?
ClassWeekly offers free worksheets and printable learning resources for kids in preschool to grade 5. All worksheets are aligned to Common Core, NGSS, and C3 Framework standards and designed by educators. Become a member to access the full library and download unlimited PDFs.