Winter Argument on Outdoor PE in Cold Weather
Written by Adi Ackerman, Head Teacher
"Winter Argument on Outdoor PE in Cold Weather" is written for 8th Grade (Ages 13-14), and it covers Common Core W.8.1.A. A 7th grader who is already steady on opinion writing can use it too, and an older student can use it as a short review.
8th grade grammar worksheet: weigh what a student, parent, PE teacher and nurse want, then argue about outdoor PE in winter. Part of our writing counter arguments collection. Aligned to Common Core standards.
How do I use this worksheet?
Use these after students can write a claim with reasons. Pair students who chose opposite sides to test each other's rebuttals.
What students will practice
- Students will mark whether a student, a parent, a PE teacher and a nurse are for or against outdoor PE.
- Students will open an argument by explaining the strongest opposing view fairly.
- Students will respond to that view and state their own position on outdoor PE in cold weather.
Hard Choices That Reveal Your Priorities
February Topic on Libraries That Lend More Than Books
Would You Rather Have a Rewind or a Preview Button?
Would You Rather Design Cities or Restore Forests?
Would You Rather Never Forget or Choose What to Forget?
Would You Rather Be a Star or a Benchwarmer?
Would You Rather Know Every Fact or Learn Fast?
Would You Rather Teach a Class or Take One?
Curriculum Links
Common Core State Standards
Writing · 8th Grade
Standard: Introduce claim(s), acknowledge and distinguish the claim(s) from alternate or opposing claims, and organize the reasons and evidence logically.
View all W.8.1.A worksheets →Find this in the curriculum
Browse the grade, subject, and topic this belongs to.
FAQ
How do I use this writing counter arguments worksheet?
⌄
Use these after students can write a claim with reasons. Pair students who chose opposite sides to test each other's rebuttals.
What does this worksheet teach?
⌄
Weigh what a student, parent, PE teacher and nurse want, then argue about outdoor PE in winter. The directions on the page read: Read the topic. Complete all four boxes in Step 1. In Step 2, open with the strongest opposing view and explain it fairly. Then respond to it and state your own position.
Can I use this writing counter arguments worksheet for homeschool or classroom?
⌄
Yes, both. We made it for 8th grade opinion writing, and it works the same at home or at school. At home, a student can work through it alone and then go over it with you, which shows quickly what is solid and what needs another look. In class it works as independent practice, homework or a warm-up, and you can print one copy or a full set.
What is a rebuttal in an argument?
⌄
A rebuttal answers the strongest objection and shows why your claim still holds. It can show the objection is mistaken, smaller than it seems or solvable, as Spring Argument on Building an Outdoor Classroom explains.
How do you introduce a counterargument?
⌄
State the opposing view fairly, admit what is right in it, then respond. Winter Argument on Outdoor PE in Cold Weather starts the paragraph with People who disagree with me believe that.
Do the counterargument worksheets have answer keys?
⌄
No. Each sheet asks students to write their own nine-line argument, so answers vary. The planning charts make it easy to check that the objection and rebuttal are there.
Ratings & Reviews
No reviews yet. Be the first to share what you think.
Reviews are for ClassWeekly members.
Make a Request
Spotted something to fix, or want a worksheet we don't have yet? Tell us and we'll make it.
Worksheet Details
| Grade | 8th Grade |
| Subject | Grammar & Writing |
| Topic | Opinion Writing |
| Standard | W.8.1.A |
| Pages | 1 page |
| Difficulty | Medium |
What is ClassWeekly?
ClassWeekly offers free worksheets and printable learning resources for kids, from preschool up. All worksheets are aligned to Common Core, NGSS, and C3 Framework standards and designed by educators. Become a member to access the full library and download unlimited PDFs.
Hard Choices That Reveal Your Priorities
February Topic on Libraries That Lend More Than Books
Would You Rather Have a Rewind or a Preview Button?
Would You Rather Design Cities or Restore Forests?
Would You Rather Never Forget or Choose What to Forget?
Would You Rather Be a Star or a Benchwarmer?
Would You Rather Know Every Fact or Learn Fast?
Would You Rather Teach a Class or Take One?